Page 1 of 1

Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Thu Apr 15, 2021 11:51 am
by tera_X
Using rk3399-sd-friendlywrt-5.10-20210402.img on my Nanopi R4S 1GB.
Installed and updated:
luci-app-sqm v5.12.0-1
sqm-scripts v1.4.0-2
collectd-mod-sqm v1.4.0-2
kmod-sched-cake v4.14.209+2019-03-12-057c7388-1

Network -> SQM QoS -> Queue Discipline -> here im missing cake as queueing disc
When i select piece of cake or layer cake as queue script i get an system error that cake is not usable when sqm qos logging is enabled. -> "SQM: ERROR: QDISC cake is NOT useable."

Terminl "tc qdisc" lists no cake either.

Tried reinstalling all sqm packages, tried to reinstall kmod_sched_cake and bricked my installation.

Need some advice on how to get cake working.

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Thu Apr 22, 2021 11:22 pm
by vision2003
Same problem here on 4gb r4s - cake discipline is missing. Any ideas?

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Thu Apr 29, 2021 10:42 am
by weber1
tera_X wrote:
Using rk3399-sd-friendlywrt-5.10-20210402.img on my Nanopi R4S 1GB.
Installed and updated:
luci-app-sqm v5.12.0-1
sqm-scripts v1.4.0-2
collectd-mod-sqm v1.4.0-2
kmod-sched-cake v4.14.209+2019-03-12-057c7388-1

Network -> SQM QoS -> Queue Discipline -> here im missing cake as queueing disc
When i select piece of cake or layer cake as queue script i get an system error that cake is not usable when sqm qos logging is enabled. -> "SQM: ERROR: QDISC cake is NOT useable."

Terminl "tc qdisc" lists no cake either.

Tried reinstalling all sqm packages, tried to reinstall kmod_sched_cake and bricked my installation.

Need some advice on how to get cake working.

This would make an interesting little router.

What performance can we expect from something like this? Gbps NAT?

Any concerns native vs PCIe Gigabit Ethernet?

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Fri May 28, 2021 11:31 pm
by S0und
'cake' option is still missing even on the latest build:

OpenWrt 19.07.5 r11257-5090152ae3 / LuCI friendlywrt-v19.07.5 branch git-20.358.36252-85ff2c9

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Sat Jul 03, 2021 4:30 am
by Naqash
tera_X wrote:
Using rk3399-sd-friendlywrt-5.10-20210402.img on my Nanopi R4S 1GB.
Installed and updated:
luci-app-sqm v5.12.0-1
sqm-scripts v1.4.0-2
collectd-mod-sqm v1.4.0-2
kmod-sched-cake v4.14.209+2019-03-12-057c7388-1

Network -> SQM QoS -> Queue Discipline -> here im missing cake as queueing disc
When i select piece of cake or layer cake as queue script i get an system error that cake is not usable when sqm qos logging is enabled. -> "SQM: ERROR: QDISC cake is NOT useable."

Terminl "tc qdisc" lists no cake either.

Tried reinstalling all sqm packages, tried to reinstall kmod_sched_cake and bricked my installation.

Need some advice on how to get cake working.



- cake discipline is missing. Have you got any solution?

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Tue Jul 06, 2021 12:15 am
by tera_X
Still no cake qdisc for me, my current guess is that the compiled/linked kernel version is too old for cake. Have to wait for native Openwrt support or link/build/compile your own kernel with the friendlywrt github repo.

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Thu Jul 22, 2021 9:43 am
by maazahmed571
tera_X wrote:
Using rk3399-sd-friendlywrt-5.10-20210402.img on my Nanopi R4S 1GB.
Installed and updated:
luci-app-sqm v5.12.0-1
sqm-scripts v1.4.0-2
collectd-mod-sqm v1.4.0-2
kmod-sched-cake v4.14.209+2019-03-12-057c7388-1

Network -> SQM QoS -> Queue Discipline -> here im missing cake as queueing disc
When i select piece of cake or layer cake as queue script i get an system error that cake is not usable when sqm qos logging is enabled. -> "SQM: ERROR: QDISC cake is NOT useable."

Terminl "tc qdisc" lists no cake either.

Tried reinstalling all sqm packages, tried to reinstall kmod_sched_cake and bricked my installation.

Need some advice on how to get cake working.


I also need the cake working

Re: Nanopi R4S 1GB need help with qdisc cake

Posted: Wed Jun 15, 2022 2:52 am
by karlmarxbl6
tera_X wrote:
Using rk3399-sd-friendlywrt-5.10-20210402.img on my Nanopi R4S 1GB.
Installed and updated:
luci-app-sqm v5.12.0-1
sqm-scripts v1.4.0-2
collectd-mod-sqm v1.4.0-2
kmod-sched-cake v4.14.209+2019-03-12-057c7388-1

Network -> SQM QoS -> Queue Discipline -> here im missing cake as queueing disc
When i select piece of cake or layer cake as queue script i get an system error that cake is not usable when sqm qos logging is enabled. -> "SQM: ERROR: QDISC cake is NOT useable."

Terminl "tc qdisc" lists no cake either.

Tried reinstalling all sqm packages, tried to reinstall kmod_sched_cake and bricked my installation.

Need some advice on how to get cake working.


Any solution for this? Cake working is important for me.